Europe
will be part of the Peace Negotiations with Russia and USA; ‘Stop Trading with
Russia’
BERLIN – While leaders of the United States, China and Russia gathered
in China to design their view of world affairs, Ukraine and its European advocates
known as the Coalition of the Willing met here on November 19 and conceived
their view of the optimum course of action for Ukraine and Europe.
Among their demands are seat at the negotiating table, Ukraine
must remain sovereign, and no agreement about Ukraine should be imposed over
the heads of Ukrainians or Europeans.
The Conference in China brought together three powers to discuss
the international order that they’re building. The other insists that Ukraine
and Europe must have a voice in determining their own future.
President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, after a day spent in talks with
European leaders and US envoys, told reporters that there was a simple way
global superpowers – mainly the United States and China — could put an end
to Russia’s full-scale invasion.
"If you want to stop war, stop trade with Russia," he
said.
Ukraine and its primary European partners also called on Russia to
halt strikes on energy facilities during the coming winter as a show of good
faith in peace negotiations, according to a joint statement issued after a
Coalition of the Willing summit in Berlin.
In a joint statement, the leaders of Germany, France, the UK, and
Ukraine called on Russia to accept both a winter energy ceasefire and a truce
allowing safe passage for food exports in the Black Sea.
"As a first step towards a cessation of hostilities, the
leaders called on Russia to agree to an energy ceasefire for the duration of
the winter," the statement reads.
Overview
The summit was hosted by German Chancellor Friedrich Merz,
alongside French President Emmanuel Macron and British Prime Minister Andy
Burnham. It was the 17th meeting of the Coalition of the Willing.
Participants included:
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy.
NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte.
EU leadership.
More than 30 heads of state and government, with 44 delegations
represented.
American presidential envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner.
The most important outcomes is the participants’ insistence that Europe
will participate in peace negotiations with Russia and the United States.
This is particularly important following the Trump–Putin–Xi
meeting in China. The Berlin participants endorsed a negotiating format
involving Ukraine, Russia, the United States and Europe.
The European negotiating group is to include the E5 countries —
France, Germany, Britain, Italy and Poland — together with EU representation.
This is a significant rejection of the idea that Washington,
Moscow and Beijing can determine Europe's future without Europe.
Security
guarantees for Ukraine
This was perhaps the most consequential part of the declaration.
The proposed arrangements include:
Legally binding security guarantees after a ceasefire.
A US-led ceasefire monitoring and verification mechanism.
A European-led multinational force for Ukraine, supported by the
United States.
Continued military, financial and technical assistance.
A commitment to take measures to restore peace and security if
Russia attacks Ukraine again, subject to national procedures.
The multinational force is not merely theoretical: participating
countries are conducting the Koalicja-2026 military exercise, primarily in
Poland.
Importantly, these are commitments to establish post-ceasefire
arrangements, not a force already deployed inside Ukraine. Nor is there yet an
unconditional American Article 5 guarantee.
Financial and military assistance
The figures are substantial:
NATO allies' military assistance in 2026, €70 billion ($82.6
billion)
Target for military assistance in 2027, At least €70 billion ($82.6
billion)
EU Ukraine Support Loan through 2027, €90 billion ($105.76
billion)
Additional EU funding proposal for 2027,€45 billion ($52.8
billion)
One distinction matters: the €45 billion is an additional
proposal, while the €90 billion ($105.76 billion) is an existing support-loan
framework. They should not be added together as if both were entirely new
commitments made at the summit.
There was also agreement to strengthen sanctions against Russian
oil and gas revenues, cryptocurrency-related financial flows, sanctions evasion
and the Russian military-industrial complex.
What did the leaders actually say?
Friedrich Merz — Germany
Europe will not allow itself to be divided again. He explicitly
rejected a new Yalta-style arrangement and emphasized that Ukraine's future
belongs in a free Europe.
Emmanuel Macron — France
Ukraine must negotiate from a position of strength. Promises of
military assistance must translate into actual deliveries, particularly
air-defense interceptors.
Volodymyr Zelenskyy — Ukraine
He emphasized air defense, protection of energy infrastructure,
winter assistance and security guarantees. He also welcomed Europe's inclusion
in negotiations.
Jared Kushner — United States
He described the American objective as a sovereign, secure and
prosperous Ukraine. Work is underway on security guarantees and a postwar
recovery framework.
What about Russia?
The leaders agreed on several principles:
International borders cannot be changed by force.
Ukraine has the sovereign right to choose its own alliances and
security arrangements.
Russian frozen sovereign assets remain immobilized until Russia
ends its aggression and compensates Ukraine.
European security cannot be renegotiated while Russia continues
its war against Ukraine.
Any decisions concerning NATO require the consent of NATO allies;
EU matters require the consent of the EU and its member states.
They also called for two immediate ceasefires:
An energy ceasefire throughout the winter.
A Black Sea ceasefire to permit food exports.
These are demands directed at Russia, not agreements already
accepted by Moscow.
The American question
This is the part that deserves particular attention. The American
representatives participated. Kushner even indicated that Russia might be
comfortable with an Article 5-like security guarantee for Ukraine.
But there is a considerable difference between an American
negotiator expressing optimism and the United States making a binding
commitment.
The actual declaration provides for American coordination and
support, but leaves important details to be negotiated.
Reuters also reported continuing European concern that President
Trump might reach an arrangement with President Putin that sidelines Ukraine or
European governments.
Assessment
First: Europe demonstrated political independence. The message to
Moscow and Washington was unmistakable: Europe will not accept decisions about
European security made without European participation.
Second: Ukraine's security is increasingly being treated as
European security. That is a fundamental shift in the political understanding
of this war.
Third: The discussion has moved beyond simply stopping the
fighting. It is now about what happens the day after a ceasefire. Who protects
Ukraine? Who monitors the agreement? What happens if Russia attacks again?
These are precisely the questions that determine whether peace will last. Ukraine needs peace, but a peace that can be defended.
No comments:
Post a Comment